The last agencies to be sold

By Tim Sutton, senior reputational adviser and PR-agency M&A counsel · November 2026

The view now forming in my trade runs like this. AI clears out the junior floor of an agency. What remains is a small firm of senior people with a margin the old pyramid never managed. A better business must be worth a better price, so the buyers will come. Private equity, to borrow the title of an article Aaron Kwittken published on LinkedIn on 9 November, is betting big on agencies.

I think the received view has the arithmetic right and the conclusion wrong. A smaller, more senior agency may be a better business. Whether it is a business anybody can buy is another question. AI may not raise the price of the senior agency at all. It may shrink the number of agencies that can be sold.

What Fairfax Cone sold

The point was made sixty-three years ago by a man who was selling at the time. On 20 September 1963 Time magazine ran a story headed Advertising: The Way For Some to Go. Foote, Cone & Belding was selling shares to the public. They were worth $6 each on the agency’s own books and were offered at $15.50.

The agency’s boss, Fairfax Cone, conceded to Time that advertising looked a risky investment, because clients are continuously switching and an agency’s only real asset is brainpower, a perishable and uncertain commodity. Then he put it better: Our inventory goes down the elevator every night. He sold 38,000 of his own shares for $541,500 and kept the rest.

Cone said this in the course of selling the inventory, at a little over two and a half times what the books said it was worth. It is the earliest source I have found for the line. I admire the timing. Most of us would wait for the cheque to clear before mentioning that the goods go home every evening.

What I said in September

I had a part in the received view and had better own up to it first. In September I wrote here that The agencies that sell well over the next five years will be smaller, more senior and higher-margin than the ones that sold well over the last five. I argued that as the junior hours fell away the buyer is increasingly paying for the relationships, the reputation, the judgment, the brand. I still think both are true.

I also wrote, in the same paragraph, that taking away the pyramid makes the founder-dependency problem worse, not better. My remedy was to spread the seniority across several names and I put it like this: A firm of a dozen, five of whom clients would follow anywhere, is a business.

On reflection, I stopped a paragraph short. A dozen senior people with loyal clients certainly make a business, but it begins to look rather like what the professions call a partnership. Which leaves a question I did not ask in September: who buys it?

What a buyer could own

A buyer pays for what is still there when the people have gone home. For most of the history of the agency that was the floor. In September I called it the machine (The pyramid is the machine.) and it was the part a buyer could count: juniors hired young, billed at several times what they cost, trained by a process and replaced, when they left, by more juniors trained by the same process. The business did not depend on clients being devoted to any particular junior, which was part of its appeal to a buyer.

The seniors were always on loan. They came with the business the way a view comes with a house, except that a view cannot hand in its notice. When my partners and I were selling Charles Barker, it was fairly clear what the buyer was counting and judging: the five of us and which of us might be disposable once they had bought the firm. This was linked closely to an assessment of who owned the most important client relationships. It is a strange feeling to be courted and sized up for both a marriage and a future divorce at the same time.

The winter of 1994

The cleanest demonstration I know of what an agency’s owners actually own is Saatchi & Saatchi in the winter of 1994. On 16 December its shareholders ousted Maurice Saatchi as chairman. It was their company and they were entitled to. On 9 January 1995 seven of its top executives resigned in solidarity with him. By 17 January British Airways, Mars and the Conservative Party were reviewing their accounts.

Later that year British Airways followed the brothers to their new agency, M&C Saatchi. So did Mirror Group. Mars took its confectionery account away as well, though not to them.

I should disclose that after the brothers had left, taking British Airways and other accounts with them, I led a Charles Barker team hired to act for Saatchi & Saatchi. It was, as you can imagine, something of a communications challenge.

So the shareholders found out what they owned. They had kept the company and the name. They had lost the founders, the airline and a good deal else. What they had left was still a business: five years later Publicis agreed to buy Saatchi & Saatchi, under its old name and without the men it was named after. It was still a business because most of an agency, in 1995, was the part that did not follow the brothers out of the door. That is the part AI is beginning to thin out.

The agency the brothers built

The brothers’ own agency is the other half of the experiment. M&C Saatchi floated in London on 14 July 2004 at a value of £67.8m. Most of the shares sold that day belonged to its executives, a move Fairfax Cone would have recognised.

Two bidders came in 2022. Vin Murria’s AdvT went first; its offer lapsed in September for lack of support. Next 15’s offer, paid partly in its own shares, valued the company at £310m when it was made and about £205m by the time the shareholders voted it down in October. It had lost a third of its value without a word of it being changed. The bids failed on price as much as anything else. M&C Saatchi is still listed and still independent. So the company the brothers left has been sold and the company they built has not.

The firms that are joined

Take the floor away and what is left is a group of senior people whom clients follow. That is a partnership in all but the paperwork. Time made the comparison in the first sentence of its 1963 story: Like law firms or other businesses that have confidential relationships with clients, nearly all U.S. advertising agencies are privately owned.

In the traditional law-firm merger, the partners generally join the enlarged firm rather than receive a purchase price for leaving it. Edge International, a US consultancy to law firms, observes that when law firms merge a purchase price is rarely paid and the partners of the smaller firm become partners of the larger one. Nobody writes a cheque. Somebody orders new letterhead.

What happened to the banks

There is an argument from economics that may help explain this, though it concerns investment banks rather than agencies. Writing in the Journal of Finance in 2008, Morrison and Wilhelm set out their case in the abstract: We argue that partnerships foster the formation of human capital and we use technological advances that undermine the role of human capital to explain the partnership’s going-public decision. Goldman Sachs floated on 4 May 1999. Put crudely, once technology had taken over work that used to live in the bankers, the bank no longer had to be owned by them.

AI may be doing something rather different to agencies. As it takes over more of the work done by juniors, the business may depend even more on particular senior people and their client relationships. That makes me wonder whether agencies could move back towards something more like a partnership. Michael Corleone said it was business, not personal. In a senior agency they are the same thing, which is the buyer’s difficulty.

What outside investors bought

Some outside shareholders in English law firms have had cause to regret it. DWF floated on 11 March 2019 at 122p. In 2023 the private equity firm Inflexion bought it at 100p a share, half as much again as the 65.5p the shares had been fetching. It takes a certain skill to pay half as much again and still hand back 22p less than the float price. Ince went into administration in April 2023 and on 30 June was sold for £2.2m. Its creditors were owed £41m, nearly nineteen times the price. These examples do not establish the cause of either firm’s difficulties, but they do raise the question of what outside investors own when so much depends on people who are free to resign.

The case against me

That is my argument. Here is the case against it, because it is a good one. First, some listed law firms are doing very well. Knights reported underlying revenue up 28 per cent to £207.7m in the year to April 2026. Keystone Law’s revenue rose 17.9 per cent to £115.2m in the year to January 2026. Its lawyers are self-employed and, in its own words, determine how, when and where they work. It calls itself a platform law firm.

Both firms appear to have built a business whose value is not wholly dependent on particular senior people. Keystone is especially interesting: its lawyers have considerable freedom over their working lives, while the firm provides the platform through which they work. That is a substantial qualification to my argument.

Second, accountancy, where private equity is buying in volume. Cinven’s 60 per cent stake valued Grant Thornton UK at about £1.5bn. Its chief executive put the buyer’s test plainly: You cannot sell something which has an awful reputation for quality because nobody will want to buy it. CPA Trendlines counted 621 deals in US accountancy from January 2016 to October 2026, 214 of them in 2026 so far. Clearly, a great many professional firms are being bought.

What the buyers are getting

So what are those buyers getting? Lee Humble of Azets told the ICAEW in April 2025: The recurring revenue they earn from core services provides excellent visibility of future income and is largely recession proof. That seems to me an important part of the answer.

A set of accounts comes round every year by law. A retainer comes round until the client’s new marketing director arrives. Nobody is required by law to hire an agency.

The best answer to me comes from Kwittken, in the article I mentioned earlier, titled Private Equity Is Betting Big on Agencies. The Real Prize? Reinventing Them as Polymorphic Firms. His argument, as I read it, is that agencies can rebuild the way they work around senior judgment, a shared store of knowledge (so that what the firm knows survives when people leave) and fees charged for outcomes in place of hours.

If an agency can build that store of knowledge, the buyer has something to own that does not use the lift. This would be closer to the process Morrison and Wilhelm describe: knowledge that once belonged to individuals becomes something the firm can retain and a buyer can acquire. It is the strongest objection to this essay.

What this does to the deal

If I am right more often than Kwittken is, the first consequence is fewer outright sales. I have no count of deals that shows this happening yet. It is a forecast and should be read as one. The second consequence is more arrangements that look like joining another firm rather than selling your own. I have written before that nobody ever sells an agency: they join, they partner, they take the next step.

The terms will move to match: longer earn-outs, more of the price paid in the buyer’s shares, lock-ins that run past the point at which a founder can remember why they agreed to them. The seller is paid for staying, which is a salary with a multiple attached. I have also written that the last of the price is paid for a promise. In a senior firm more of the price will be.

From the seller’s chair it looks like this. For the next three to four years, depending on the deal, you are required to be charm personified and you learn to method act how happy you are to be with your new friends. All the while, you are privately counting how every month that passes affects your exit.

When there is no buyer

For the firm that cannot be sold at all, succession becomes what it is in a law firm: the next tier buying in. The employee ownership trust was the tidy version of that. It is less tidy now. Under the government’s policy paper, from 26 November 2025 half the gain is taxed on the sale. Before, none of it was.

There is a separate argument about who keeps the saving AI makes, the agency or its client. It bears on the price and I will not settle it here.

You may also have noticed who is making this argument. It leaves me in the unfortunate position of an adviser on agency sales arguing that there may be fewer of them.

What a buyer can still own

Some things do stay in the building when the people go home and a buyer can own them. Income that recurs under contract is the first. The accountants have shown what a buyer will pay for it. A retainer that renews on terms written down is worth more than one that renews out of habit.

A method written down and held by the firm is another: how the firm runs a pitch, a crisis, a product launch or the monthly report nobody reads, set out so that a new senior can pick it up on a Monday.

Client knowledge kept by the firm and not in one partner’s head is the third, which is Kwittken’s store of knowledge by another name. A name that brings in work no partner chased is the fourth. How long a name survives a sale is a question I asked about Shandwick.

The last is a second tier that clients already ring. If the client calls the founder’s deputy while the founder is on holiday and is happy with the answer, the buyer has a business. If the client waits for the founder to come back, the buyer has a founder.

These things take years to build; hiring more people will not, by itself, achieve them. By the time a buyer starts examining the business, there may be very little opportunity to remedy their absence.

If I had to choose where a founder should begin, it would be here. What is the business worth if you are no longer in it? By the way, that’s a question you should be asking even if you aren’t contemplating a sale. A sale is only one of the ways a founder leaves.

Down in the lift

Fairfax Cone’s observation has survived rather well since 1963. If AI takes over much of the junior work, an agency may have fewer people and better margins, but depend more heavily on the senior people who remain.

The inventory still goes down in the lift every night. There is now much less of it and it knows what it is worth.

First published in The Sutton Memo on Substack on 14 November 2026. New essays go out by email first: subscribe free.

If you are weighing how much of an agency leaves when its founder does, that is the subject of what a buyer actually owns when the founder is the business.

Speak with Tim in confidence

or email tim@timsuttonpr.com

Common questions

Will AI make PR agencies easier to sell?

Not necessarily. Tim Sutton argues that AI may make agencies smaller, more senior and more profitable, and also harder to sell. As AI takes over junior work, the business may depend even more on particular senior people and their client relationships, and those people are free to leave. He expects fewer outright sales, and says plainly that this is a forecast: he has no count of deals that shows it yet.

What does a buyer actually own when it buys a PR agency?

What stays in the building when the people go home. Tim Sutton lists five things: income that recurs under contract, a method written down and held by the firm, client knowledge kept by the firm rather than in one partner's head, a name that brings in work no partner chased, and a second tier that clients already ring. Each takes years to build, and once a buyer starts examining the business there may be little time to fix their absence.

How will AI change the terms of a PR agency sale?

If his argument holds, Tim Sutton expects more deals that look like joining another firm rather than selling your own, with longer earn-outs, more of the price paid in the buyer's shares and longer lock-ins. The seller is paid for staying, which he calls a salary with a multiple attached. In a senior firm, more of the price will be paid for a promise.

How has the tax on selling an agency to an employee ownership trust changed?

From 26 November 2025 half the gain on a sale to an employee ownership trust is taxed, where before none of it was, according to the government policy paper Tim Sutton cites. He calls the trust the tidy version of the next tier buying in, and says it is less tidy now. For a firm that cannot be sold at all, he expects succession to become what it is in a law firm.

Tim Sutton is a senior reputational adviser to boards in their hardest moments and counsel to PR-agency principals on one side of any given transaction. timsuttonpr.com · LinkedIn · Privacy · Legal